MonolithIC 3D Inc., the Next Generation 3D-IC Company
  • Home
  • Technology
    • Technology
    • Papers, Presentations and Patents
    • Overview >
      • Background
      • Why Monolithic 3D?
      • Paths to Monolithic 3D
      • Applications
    • Ion-Cut: The Building Block
    • Monolithic 3D Logic >
      • RCAT
      • HKMG
      • Laser Annealing
      • RCJLT
      • 3D Embedded RAM
      • 3D Gate Array
      • FPGA
      • Ultra Large Integration - Redundancy and Repair
    • Monolithic 3D Memory >
      • 3D DRAM
      • 3D Resistive Memories
      • 3D Flash
    • Monolithic 3D Electro-Optics >
      • 3D Image Sensors
      • 3D Micro-Displays
  • Record of Invention
  • Licensing
  • 3D-IC Edge
    • 3D-IC Edge
    • Simulators
  • News & Events
    • News & Events
    • S3S15 Game Change 2.0 Video/P
    • Webcast
    • Webinar
    • Press Releases
    • In the News
    • Upcoming Events
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • History
    • Team
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
  • Blog

Why Injunctions - or at Least Exclusion - Are Vital to Domestic Semiconductor Innovation

10/23/2026

0 Comments

 
By Zvi Or-Bach, MonolithIC 3D Inc., October 2026
​

Part 3 of a three-part series on memory, invention, and licensing, written from MonolithIC 3D's vantage point, which has published and patented 3D integration since 2010.
​
For decades, patents did more than merely protect products; they enabled a market for technology itself. SanDisk built portfolio licenses with Intel, Toshiba, and Samsung in the 1990s, with court records reporting running royalties on worldwide flash sales [1]; FTC records describe Rambus's early DRAM licenses at roughly 1% to 2.5% [14]; Tessera's publicly filed Micron agreement combined upfront payments with continuing quarterly royalties [10]. An inventor could build a substantial business by licensing semiconductor innovation to the manufacturers best positioned to commercialize it.

​What changed?
​
In eBay v. MercExchange (2006), the Supreme Court replaced the near-automatic injunction after a finding of infringement with a four-factor test [2]. The Court expressly noted that self-made inventors who prefer to license may well qualify, but the practical bargaining environment changed. When infringement can credibly end in exclusion, the commercial question is:

       Should we take a license, or risk losing the ability to sell the product?

When the likely remedy is only money, and only after years of litigation, it can become:

       Why license now rather than litigate first?

A 2023 study in the Strategic Management Journal (Ozden & Khashabi) confirmed the effect empirically: the reduced probability of injunctions reduced U.S. firms' propensity to license their technology, hitting smaller firms hardest. [7]

The America Invents Act then added the PTAB, so a patent owner may defend the same patent simultaneously in court and in a Patent Office validity proceeding. A 2024 GAO report found consequences for financing: fewer law firms take patent cases on contingency, and third-party litigation funders can require two to three times their investment back before the patent owner sees proceeds [8]. What was once:

       Inventor → Patent → Manufacturer → License

became:
​
       Inventor → Lawyers → Funding → Multiple proceedings → Litigation → Settlement.

​​
A first-hand data point

I can add my own experience. We founded MonolithIC 3D in early 2009 with my own resources, and over the years tried to raise capital in every form the market offers: secured loans against the patents, joint ventures with semiconductor and electronics companies, venture capital. Despite building a growing portfolio in a field the industry was clearly moving toward, we never even reached serious discussions. We didn't see revenue until late 2020, more than a decade and many millions of dollars later, when we sold 21 patents to Samsung. The lesson: when exclusion is not credible, patents make weak collateral and licensing revenue is treated as speculative [9]. The inventor funds the invention, or not at all.
​
And our experience is not an outlier. Our own informal survey suggests that the twenty-five years before 2010 produced a steady stream of invention-based semiconductor licensing companies - MOSAID, Qualcomm, SanDisk, Rambus, Tessera, Saifun, eMemory, several of them venture-backed and publicly listed - while it is hard to name even one founded on that model in the fifteen years since. And this was exactly the wrong period for such a drought: the years before 2010 were classical Moore's Law scaling on the planar CMOS transistor, while the years since brought far more fundamental change - FinFET, gate-all-around, 3D NAND, 3D integration - the kind of foundational invention that historically spawned licensing companies. More invention should have produced more inventor companies; instead it produced almost none.
Picture
VC funding share to patent-intensive businesses

The exception that proves the rule

One venue still treats exclusion differently: Section 337 proceedings at the U.S. International Trade Commission, where the Federal Circuit held (Spansion v. ITC, 2010) that the eBay test does not apply [11]. ITC cases are not easy - infringement and a domestic industry must be proven, validity defenses remain, and investigations average about 16 months [12] - but the remedy is exclusion, and the ITC expressly recognizes complainants that rely on licensing rather than manufacturing [13].

This difference was on display this summer. Netlist won a $303 million jury verdict against Samsung in 2023, and a separate case later added a judgment of over $100 million; yet years of appeals and PTAB challenges followed, with the judgments unpaid. Netlist then filed two Section 337 complaints (the first filed on September 30, 2025). In August 2026, after about a year at the ITC and before any ITC hearing, the parties settled comprehensively: license fees of up to $750 million to Netlist over five years - with the total Samsung obligation approaching $900 million - plus a patent cross-license, a supply agreement, and an end to all pending matters between them [15, 16]. A decade of district-court litigation produced judgments; a comprehensive license followed within a year of the ITC filings. Timing does not prove motive, and the settlement resolved many proceedings at once - but as an illustration of what a credible exclusion remedy changes, the sequence is clear.

The same patent owner then repeated the demonstration. Netlist approached Micron about a license in April 2021 and was turned down; it sued in the Eastern District of Texas in 2022, and Micron answered by challenging the asserted patents at the Patent Office [21]. In May 2024 a jury found willful infringement and awarded $445 million, even though the Patent Office had already found the principal patent's claims unpatentable [22]. The two tracks ran in parallel for years. On September 2, 2026 the Federal Circuit affirmed the invalidation of five other Netlist patents asserted against Micron, and a week later it heard argument on the two patents behind the verdict, with reporting from the hearing describing the panel as skeptical of Netlist's position [23, 24]. More than five years after the license request, and more than two years after the jury spoke, nothing had been paid, and the verdict itself remained uncertain. Then, in September 2026, Netlist filed a new Section 337 complaint seeking to exclude Micron memory products from the U.S. market [25]. On October 6, 2026, weeks later, the companies announced a comprehensive resolution: a settlement of all pending proceedings and a five-year license to Netlist's entire patent portfolio for $30 million per quarter, $600 million total [25, 26]. Five years of money-only litigation produced a verdict that never became money; within weeks, an exclusion filing was followed by a signed license. Twice in two months, with two different manufacturers, the same sequence played out.

Netlist's experience is not unusual; it is the norm. A Berkeley Haas study of every patent damages award above $10 million appealed to the Federal Circuit from 2010 to 2025 found that only about a third survived intact; outside biotech, awards above $100 million held up only about one time in ten, and not one award above $1 billion survived [27]. Even the people who finance these cases agree: after a jury returned a record $5.7 billion patent verdict in September 2026, the litigation funder behind the plaintiff told its investors that "very few large patent verdicts survive the post-verdict process intact" [28]. A money-only remedy that arrives years late, and rarely intact, gives a manufacturer every reason to litigate first; a credible exclusion order gives it a reason to license now.

What history says about the stakes

This is not a niche legal debate; it is a lesson nations have learned before. England's Statute of Monopolies (1624) swept away crown-granted monopolies with one exception: exclusive rights for the true inventor of a new manufacture, for a limited term [17]. Within a few generations England became the workshop of the world, and economic historians count its enforceable patent rights among the institutions that made the Industrial Revolution British and underwrote the national wealth and power that followed. The American founders understood the lesson well enough to write the same bargain into the Constitution [18]. And if strong, enforceable patent rights could do that in an age of steam and steel, the stakes are far higher today.
​
Fifty years ago, the value of America's largest companies lay mostly in things one could touch: plants, equipment, inventory. Today that relationship has inverted, and most of the S&P 500's market value resides in intangible assets, designs, software, processes, and the patents that protect them [19]. The Patent Office's latest accounting finds that IP-intensive industries now generate more than 40% of U.S. GDP and pay a substantial wage premium over the rest of the economy [20]. Exclusion matters more in this economy, not less, because of the nature of the assets themselves: a modern process technology takes years and enormous sums to develop, yet once disclosed in a published patent, it can be copied at a fab anywhere in the world at almost no additional cost. What separates that disclosure from a free ride is the credible ability to exclude. In the information era, technology leadership drives national wealth beyond anything else, and the nation whose inventors are protected is the nation whose inventors keep inventing - and disclosing.

The policy question

       If society wants inventors to disclose their innovations rather than keep them secret, should the           patent system provide a practical path for those inventions to become commercially licensable            assets again?
​

Policymakers are interacting with it. The bipartisan RESTORE Patent Rights Act (S. 708 / H.R. 1574), introduced and pending in committee, would restore a presumption of injunction after final judgment of infringement [3], and the Department of Justice and the USPTO have jointly emphasized that unduly limiting injunctive relief undermines incentives to innovate, and that the public interest strongly favors enforcement of valid patent rights through exclusion orders [4, 5, 6]. For semiconductor innovation, where a small technical team can contribute ideas eventually manufactured at enormous global scale, the answer matters.
​
References
  1. SanDisk Corp. v. Kingston Technology Co.: federal court discussion of SanDisk’s historical Intel, Toshiba, and Samsung portfolio licenses and royalty structure
  2. eBay Inc. v. MercExchange, L.L.C., 547 U.S. 388 (2006)
  3. RESTORE Patent Rights Act of 2025, S. 708 / H.R. 1574, 119th Congress
  4. U.S. Department of Justice and U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, Statement of Interest, Collision Communications Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (Feb. 27, 2026)
  5. U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, “USPTO and DOJ file statement of interest reaffirming the importance of incentives to innovate” (Feb. 27, 2026)
  6. U.S. Department of Justice and U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, Joint Comment on the Public Interest before the U.S. International Trade Commission (Nov. 25, 2025)
  7. S. Aydin Ozden & P. Khashabi, “Patent Remedies and Technology Licensing: Evidence from a Supreme Court Decision,” Strategic Management Journal 44(9): 2311-2338 (2023)
  8. U.S. Government Accountability Office, “Intellectual Property: Information on Third-Party Funding of Patent Litigation,” GAO-25-107214 (Dec. 5, 2024)
  9. M. Schultz, “The Importance of an Effective and Reliable Patent System to Investment in Critical Technologies,” Alliance of U.S. Startups and Inventors for Jobs (July 2020)
  10. Tessera-Micron License Agreement (SEC filing, 2006)
  11. Spansion, Inc. v. International Trade Commission, 629 F.3d 1331 (Fed. Cir. 2010)
  12. U.S. International Trade Commission, Section 337 statistics: average length of investigations
  13. U.S. International Trade Commission, Section 337 statistics: complainants that are non-practicing entities
  14. Federal Trade Commission, In the Matter of Rambus Inc., Docket No. 9302
  15. Sterne Kessler, “Client Netlist Negotiates Five-Year Patent Alliance With Samsung” (Aug 10, 2026)
  16. ip fray, “Netlist, Samsung settle multi-venue patent dispute, sign five-year memory patent cross-licensing deal” (Aug 5, 2026)
  17. Statute of Monopolies 1623 (21 Jac. 1, c. 3), legislation.gov.uk
  18. U.S. Constitution, Article I, Section 8, Clause 8 (National Archives)

(Research and drafting assisted by AI tools. The analysis and conclusions are presented for discussion and do not address the merits of any pending or contemplated legal proceeding.)
​

This article is for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice or a statement regarding infringement, validity, liability, remedy, or any pending proceeding.
​
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Search Blog


    Meet the Bloggers


    Follow us


    To get email updates subscribe here:


    Recommended Links

    3D IC Community
    3D IC LinkedIn Discussion Group

    Recommended Blogs

    • 3D InCites by Francoise von Trapp
    • EDA360 Insider by Steve Leibson
    • Insights From the Leading Edge by Phil Garrou
    • SemiWiki by Daniel Nenni, Paul Mc Lellan, et al.

    Archives

    October 2026
    August 2026
    July 2026
    May 2026
    July 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    May 2023
    March 2022
    December 2021
    August 2021
    August 2018
    July 2018
    May 2018
    October 2017
    September 2017
    December 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    August 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011

    Categories

    All
    3d Design And Cad
    3d Ic
    3dic
    3d Nand
    3d Stacking
    3d Technology
    Brian Cronquist
    Dean Stevens
    Deepak Sekar
    Dram
    Education
    Heat Removal And Power Delivery
    Industry News
    Israel Beinglass
    Iulia Morariu
    Iulia Tomut
    Monolithic 3d
    Monolithic3d
    Monolithic 3d Inc.
    MonolithIC 3D Inc.
    Monolithic 3d Technology
    Moore Law
    Outsourcing
    Paul Lim
    Repair
    Sandisk
    Semiconductor
    Semiconductor Business
    Tsv
    Zeev Wurman
    Zvi Or Bach
    Zvi Or-Bach

    RSS Feed

© 2009–2026 MonolithIC 3D Inc., Allen, Texas. All Rights Reserved. More than 400 issued US patents.